Free Banking?

Last night, my wife and I went for our yearly meeting with our current bank to move some money around, update our kids’ RESPs and to attempt to receive Free Banking. My wife was sure that this was not going to happen, and that we were going to walk out of their empty handed, and I would be ranting about how we have to change banks. I guessed I might get something, given I had some compelling arguments, so we had a friendly wager(my wife taking the “We are going to continue paying bank fees” side of the bet) for a sweet treat at a local food establishment.

Now if you don’t remember my compelling arguments were outlined in yesterday’s posting: Changings Banks? but I thought of 1 or 2 other arguments just in case.

My extra arguments that I thought of on the spot during the discussions were:

  • If I walked into the Bank of Montreal down the road, and say, I’d like to transfer all of my banking to this branch today, if you give me free banking for a year, I am sure they would comply with my request (and if they didn’t I could simply go to the Scotiabank in the same mall and ask them for the same deal).
  • Why if I was a new client, you would give me a free iPod which retails for about $130, yet as a customer in good standing, you expect me to pay $156 a year to use your bank?
Very High Bank Fees

Very High Bank Fees

The meeting was quite cordial, and we got the banking we needed done, and we were very happy with the service that we received, but when we were left alone, my wife was still adamant that we would not get any concessions (and I was starting to wonder if she was right).

The counter points made by my bank representative were:

  • PC Financial and ING (now Tangerine) have no service charges because they are virtual banks and have much lower overhead, due to them not really having “branches”. This is an interesting argument, except that PC Financial isn’t even really a bank, it is a FRONT to CIBC right now.
  • There is a policy not to give free banking services to anyone, since this is a business. As a share holder in TD I am glad to hear that, since I like seeing companies I invest in profit, however as a customer I am not happy to hear that.
  • An implied argument, but never stated directly was, “If I give YOU free banking, everybody will want it”, which is very true.
  • If I carried the minimum balance in my checking account (I think it is $1000) I would get free banking (i.e. no bank fees would be charged), so why wasn’t I doing that? I pointed out $1000 in my bank account does me little good, but $1000 paid on my debts, does a great deal of good. My guess is if I ever get out of debt, I will carry a balance and get free banking (of course by then I will get the Senior Citizen discount).

What was the final resolution of this discussion? Well, I promised the bank representative that I would not say, and I will abide by that agreement.

Later in the evening I did enjoy the Dairy Queen Blizzard that my wife bought for me, and I will enjoy it for the entire year.

{ 13 comments }

{ 3 comments… add one }

  • Scott March 3, 2011, 9:05 AM

    Hi Big Cajun,

    I love this story. It’s too bad most Canadians just pay what they are told. (I guess we are too polite)

    Anyway, I have a newsletter that I send to about 600 of my clients and would love to include a version of this to them.

    Could you contact me to discuss?

    Thx

    Scott

    Reply
  • Big Cajun Man December 31, 2007, 10:11 AM

    I was not bluffing, when I told them that I would get up and leave their bank. I already have accounts with PC Financial and the Bank of Montreal will gladly take me back (I have been told) as well.

    You cannot be bluffing when you ask for free banking.

    Reply
  • Brian Dorion December 31, 2007, 9:18 AM

    I wish you would let me know how you convinced them. I have $20,000 in debt with TD and when I tried to negotiate no fees on the Infinity Account, they would not budge.

    Perhaps I did not emphasize the debt that I was carrying with them enough.

    Anyhow, congratulations on your free banking.

    Reply

Leave a Comment

*

%d bloggers like this: