“I’m an indexer. I don’t care what the indexes did today!”

in Index Fund, Investments

“I’m an indexer. I don’t care what the indexes did today!” 
— Preet Banerjee (2014)

These words are from financial Media Maven Preet Banerjee , and in that quip he captures the essence of the Index Investing. Couch Potato investing is another name for it.

Balanced in What Way?
All Index Investors Do is Balance

Some think it is prudent to monitor the stock market closely. I know people that do that. Some  people get upset by the “moods of the markets”, my question is: why?

If you are that worried about your investments, maybe you should not be investing in stocks ? If you are a day trader then yes, you should be on top of things (and NO you should not be a day trader, if you are asking me), but if you feel your investments are that “tenuous” then  you really need to review your Savings plan, and maybe get out of securities?

Couch Potato investing  assumes you are not changing your portfolio often. I guess your only problem after that is figuring out what you can do with all that spare time? There are enough things in life to worry about, watching your investments daily simply makes you more tense.

How you rebalance your portfolio is up to you, you can add more funds and use that to get back to your goal distribution of funds, or you can “buy and sell” to rebalance the existing funds. No matter how you rebalance, that is about all you are doing with your investments.

What if the markets crash? (yes that is a link to the 2008 crash that we all seem to have forgotten about) Not much to do about it, better to not look then especially! Market corrections happen, as with most investing strategies, attempting to dodge a market correction is a tricky dance, and most “market timing” strategies will fail in the long run (in my opinion, of course). I am sure there are folks who will sell you a great “market timing” strategy, and they are rich (selling the strategy, not the market timing). I am investigating the Fibonacci method for market timing. Anything that has Fibonacci in it is fun to read (but NO I will not use it, I just like reading about strategies and attempt to debunk them).

Index Investing Bubble ?

Most of the folks who claim to be Index Fund Investors (or Couch Potatoes), typically are not solely invested in Index Funds (or ETFs). They will hold securities in single companies as well, or they might use Dividend Investing ideas as well.

I am mostly invested in Index Funds and Index Based ETFs, however, it is not completely. I do hold a few stocks in a few of my portfolios.

Why am I still holding these stocks? Mostly they keep performing well, and pay nice dividends, I have expunged a few Single stocks from my RRSPs (Power Corp, to name one), but I hold onto my other Single Stock darlings mostly because I can’t seem to convince myself to sell them (and simply buy more Index Funds). Am I a hypocrite? If hypocrite is “Do as I say, not as I do”, then yes, I am an Index Fund Hypocrite, or maybe a Couch Yam?


  • Jacqui583 January 31, 2016, 10:20 AM

    I was thinking that I am a 100% Couch Potato-er, but then I have to consider than I retired last year (at 53) with a full company pension that gives me some breathing room as to what my investments do. I don’t know that I would feel so “brave” going all in with indexing if I didn’t have my pension.

    • bigcajunman January 31, 2016, 11:00 AM

      Is your trepidation about the fact that you are “all in” on Indexes (and not holding GICs and bonds)? Can’t see that being an Indexer is a “brave” thing, it is more the safer thing to do if you are going to be in stocks.

  • My Own Advisor August 19, 2014, 9:09 AM

    No pure potato or yam here…I hold both indexed products and dividend paying stocks. I figure I get the best of both worlds, total return from the indexes and passive income from the stocks if and when I need it.

    There are very few pure indexers I bet.

    Preet’s comment was a good one. 😉

  • Denis August 19, 2014, 3:27 AM

    Oh NO!!! Please say it isn’t so!!! Not a couch yam!!! You are one of THOSE!!!!

    You know what I mean! Healthier and tastier than potatoes!!!

    I just want my FRIES!!! Preferably as a poutine! (grin)

  • Bernie August 19, 2014, 12:03 AM

    There is absolutely nothing wrong with being average!

  • debt debs August 18, 2014, 8:54 PM

    I wanna be an Index Fund Hypocrite some day! Or is that a Dividend Stock Hypocrite? Okay I’ll settle for an Index Dividend Couch Yammer.

  • Robert_M August 18, 2014, 1:47 PM

    Becoming an indexer is a journey that can take several years. I have converted a most of my investments to a couch potato strategy, but I have some active funds that will be around for a while. That is because my ‘advisor’ who supposededly had my best interests at heart, locked me into DSC funds with a 7 year term. I still have a few years to go.

    However, the peace of mind having money in instruments that are transparent and predictable is fantastic. I know how the money is allocated and I can easily follow the trends. This has been an amazing eye opener.

    Keep up the good work.

  • aB August 18, 2014, 11:11 AM

    Couch Yam .. love it.


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Become a Tangerine client today
%d bloggers like this: